3D Poly-Mesh Models vs Photography: A Detailed Comparison

58
Written by jayargonaut

I want to discuss briefly the benefits, and of course negatives, of using three dimensional poly-mesh models and renders of them over photography when it comes to creating images of items or products. For me and for this post, I am focusing on one particular item: a watch that has been around and enjoyed by owners for many years. I was asked to model this watch and produce some fresh-looking renders.

I would imagine many people have no real concept of what a 3D mesh model is, nor what is involved in constructing one. A 3D mesh model is essentially a representation of a three-dimensional object that is created using points in a virtual space, known as vertices. These vertices are connected by edges to form faces, which are typically triangular or quadrilateral shapes. For this example, you are literally re-building the item, or watch in this case, exactly in terms of shape, size, and dimensions, by using vertices in a 3D environment that in turn creates many polygons, and in turn builds up your 3D mesh model. This process allows for high levels of detail and accuracy, resulting in a realistic and visually appealing representation of the original object. Moreover, understanding the intricacies of constructing a 3D mesh model opens the door to numerous creative possibilities, including animation, game design, and virtual reality, ultimately highlighting the significant role that 3D modeling plays in modern digital artistry and technology.

Okay, so first lets have a look at some actual photography of the watch that I am modelling for this example:

To create the renders you will see further down in this post, I had to construct the poly mesh model of the watch you see above. To do this, I constructed the model in one of my favorite modeling programs: Blender 4.2. Here lies one of the negatives I suppose of using 3d mesh-models, and that is the time to construct the model, for this example it probably took me about a week to build the model. Of course, a huge benefit is that once the model is built, you can use it again and again in many different scenes, change the colours, change the materials used, i.e different leathers or case metals.

So lets have a look at the mesh model and how it is constructed of vertices and polygons:

Now lets look at some of my varying renders of this mesh model above with materials and scenery added:

As you can see the finished results are very nice, and varied, this of course being just one of the huge benefits of 3-Dimensional mesh models over products photography, and that being the ability to vary the scenes, scene lighting, and product details very quickly and easily.

So let’s look at these benefits and negatives of using three-dimensional mesh models and renders over photography when it comes to creating product photography. One significant advantage is the ability to manipulate lighting and angles digitally, allowing for a variety of visual styles that may be difficult to achieve with traditional photography. Additionally, 3D renders can provide a level of detail and precision that ensures every aspect of the product is captured perfectly, making it easier to highlight key features. On the flip side, while three-dimensional models offer flexibility, they may sometimes lack the authentic feel that actual photographs provide, potentially leading to a disconnect between the representation and the actual product. Moreover, the initial time investment and technical expertise required to create high-quality 3D models can be a hurdle for some businesses, especially smaller ones. Overall, the choice between 3D rendering and photography often depends on the specific goals and needs of the brand, balancing authenticity with creative control.

Lets summarize the main benefits of using this method over traditional photography

  • Cost Efficiency:
    • Eliminates the need for physical prototypes, props, and locations.
    • Reduces expenses associated with professional photographers, models, and studio setups.

  • Flexibility & Customization:
    • Easily modify product designs, colors, textures, and lighting without physical changes.
    • Quickly create variations of a product (e.g., different colors, angles, or environments) without re-shooting.

  • Faster Turnaround Time:
    • Speeds up the process of creating high-quality images, particularly for new or customizable products.
    • No need to schedule photo-shoots or wait for products to be produced or shipped.

  • Unlimited Angle & Viewpoint Options:
    • Provides the ability to showcase products from any angle or viewpoint, even uncommon or impractical ones, with no physical limitations.

  • Consistency Across Visuals:
    • Ensures uniform lighting, camera settings, and product positioning across all images.
    • Ideal for creating a consistent look for product lines or catalogues.

  • No Environmental Constraints:
    • No need to worry about lighting conditions, background setup, or external factors (e.g., weather, location permits).

  • Enhanced Detailing & Precision:
    • Allows for fine-tuned control over textures, shadows, and materials for hyper-realistic or stylized representations.
    • Can model complex shapes or features that are hard to capture through traditional photography.

  • Integration with Augmented Reality (AR):
    • 3D models can be directly integrated into AR experiences, enabling interactive product visualization.

  • Virtual Prototyping:
    • Can be used for testing and visualizing designs before manufacturing, reducing the need for physical prototypes.

  • Post-Processing Control:
    • Offers easy post-production adjustments (e.g., lighting, texture changes, or backgrounds) without re-shooting or re-shooting the product.

  • Sustainability:
    • Reduces waste by eliminating the need for multiple physical samples or sets for photoshoots.

Okay, that is it for this post, I hope you enjoyed it and found it informative. If you would like any help or more information on 3D mesh modelling and rendering, please feel free to contact me.

Have a great day everyone😊.

Kind regards, Jay

Jayargonaut

Discover more from Jayargonaut - Watch Designer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

58 Comments

  2. Classics designs Jay! Very sleek as usual. I was curious as to whether you design the mechanics of these watches as well. If you don’t then do you receive specs from your clients so you can create form over their functions? I found the benefits of virtual designs that you mentioned to be useful. Would love to know more. Cheers!

    Liked by 3 people

    Reply

    1. Hi Ajinkya. Thank you for the compliment😊. Typically, I do not design the workings for the watches. Given enough time I could, but that is the key, enough time. I am usually quite constrained by time and cost. I do tend to stick to outside visual design for watches, but occasionally get involved with other aspects. Yes, I work from specs.
      Glad you enjoyed the post Ajinkya. Feel free to contact me if you need help in any aspect. Kind regards, Jay😊.

      Liked by 3 people

      Reply

  4. To me, the primary difference between photographs and digital renderings is the “fuzziness” of the photos versus the sharpness of the renderings.

    For example, you can over-sharpen a photograph and it looks constructed. Likewise, you can soften a digital image to make it look more like a photo.

    DxO FilmPack is an app that simulates film (I presume there are others). I occasionally use it to achieve certain looks. Does Blender have anything like it? Meaning, something to simulate a film image rather than a 3D rendering?

    Do you apply any ‘softening’ to your renderings? It looks like it for some of your images.

    Anyway, great renderings with lots of details and realistic textures.

    Liked by 3 people

    Reply

    1. Hi Emilio. Yes, this is a good point, and I do apply things like this to renders sometimes, depending on the result required.

      I have not heard of the App you mention, but in answer to your question about Blender, yes it does in its own way. Blender has a compositor mode that is node based (pretty much like many aspects of Blender now). What this means is: you can apply effects, such as contrast, filters (such as fuzziness, de-noise etc), alpha overlays, and many others post effects to the render. What I mean by node based is essentially these are nodes of code/functions that create effects that you can build up by plugging into each other. This sounds abstract and intimidating to the novice, but once you start to understand the process, it is very intuitive and creative.

      I also have to admit I do like to use Adobe Photoshop now for post processing too, the latest version is very useful, especially the ‘Raw Camera Filter’ where you can control many aspects of the image such as Clarity, Fuzziness, Grain, Colour, and a host of aspects that are too many to mention here.

      So yes, this does form a fairly big part of images sometimes, of course this is post processing and detail, but can increase the quality of final renders.

      Thank you for your comments and compliment Emilio, I do appreciate them.

      Kind regards, Jay

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

  5. Very nice! Even though I know these are 3D renderings, there a some that I can’t tell the difference from a photo. There a couple where the transition from bright and shiny to duller stick out, but if I were not looking for clues, I doubt I would have noted it. I’m envious of your patience (not to mention talent) for doing this kind of work.

    Liked by 3 people

    Reply

    1. Hi David. Thank you for your wonderful compliment, and your keen eye.

      Yes, as will will probably understand this all comes down to constraint of time sometimes. The process of modelling and rendering, though a wonderful one in terms of cost in many ways, takes quite some time, all work costs money and sometimes I am tasked with producing my best results in a certain constrained time. So sometimes it has to be just good enough, if you see what I mean, even though I know given enough time, I know it could be better😊.

      So I know what you mean for sure. I look at these renders and with some of them I know… ‘ahh’, I could go back and make that better, or that shadow softer, the grain stronger on that paint, or those scratches softer (for a lightly OCD person that can be a nightmare loop😄), but I have to move on to the next project. Maybe I will come back to it when time permits. maybe it is the same in many creative endeavors?

      Also, just a note, and it is most probably the same with photography, a lot is down to lighting (maybe one of the hardest parts to get right). The renders work well, but two aspects, and one you might be noting; damage – as in the top image create more realism, but I have to be careful not to put too much wear on new products. And also, as in the second ‘Parchment coloured dial’ artistic shot, the transition is a little harsh and shadows a little too harsh, this could be the GOBO lighting being too strong, or the IOR of the material needs playing around with. Either way it will have to wait to another day when I have the time to play with it.

      Hope this helps, and a great point that I always like to discuss and delve into.

      Thanks again for the great compliment David.

      Kind regards, Jay

      Liked by 3 people

      Reply

      1. Your welcome, and yes lighting/light is very important. With photography, white subjects can be tricky because white reflects the light which causes a loss of detail. Black absorbs light, so there is a loss of detail there. So, when it comes to lighting and the difficulties it can create, I feel your pain. 🙂

        Liked by 3 people

        Reply

        1. Thank you David. That is a good and simple explanation. I am no major photographer, but years ago I did spend quite a period photographing watches, and boy they were hard to get right! That is maybe, partially, what pushed me into the rendering world, as you have so much control over all these aspects. Of course you have another problem then of creating a real image in a mostly artificial environment, but the tech is getting better all the time in terms of colour management etc.

          I have a great respect for great photography and photographers!

          Best, Jay😊

          Liked by 3 people

          Reply

    1. Hi Sergei. Not really. I haven’t found anything useful in AI in what I would need – in terms of constructing build ready watch designs, especially when creating something from imagination or a specific design request. I just don’t see how it can be done, at this stage at least.

      AI has its use in terms of post processing visual renders, in Adobe photoshop for example, in speeding up many processes. I once tried, very briefly, some form of AI in producing low-poly game type models; so in terms of game assets, or the like, then it might be useful, and of course very quick! But it is a huge leap to go from this, to constructing an entire design that meets personal tastes, high-tolerance engineering specs, manufacturers specific requirements, and also the visual artistic element you might be looking for.

      Of course I am always open to looking and learning new ideas, and tech, when presented!

      I hope this all makes sense, and helps.

      Kind regards, Jay😊.

      Liked by 3 people

      Reply

  8. Well, this is fabulously fascinating, Jay.

    I wonder how it could be useful to me? I don’t know, yet, but would never rule anything out.

    The thing I like the best is the aspects of lighting.. I so know about the insanity and time taken to light an object, or a scene. Also, no matter how fabulous the image comes out, if you want a different mood/ high lighting of details, you need to relight, or reposition within existing lighting.

    The watch looks marvellous, and your featured options sublime.

    Thank you so much & cheers,

    Resa

    Liked by 4 people

    Reply

    1. Hi Resa. Thank you so much for your wonderful compliments!

      Yes, the dreaded lighting, it is the part you don’t much think about when you start out, but as time goes by you realize how important it is, and how difficult it can be!

      The rendering environment most certainly helps with this as you have so much control, and so easily once you have learnt how to manipulate the lights. Blender, the software of choice for me, even has something called ‘light-linking’, which allows you to choose which objects will, or will not, be lit in a scene. So, for example, you can have two objects next to each other in the same scene, and choose one to be lit by the lights…and the other not! So much control!

      I am glad you like the watch Resa😊.

      Kind regards, Jay

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

    1. Thank you Valerie for that kind comment😊. I am glad you like it. There are, I believe two still left available, if he is interested in the light parchment dial version: https://haroldpinchbeck.co.uk/watchmakers-special

      After this they will be all sold and the company want to modify the dial slightly, with font variation and some new colours, including matching leather strap threads. The design and colours aren’t yet definitely settled upon, but can give you a sneak peek:

      Kind regards, Jay😊

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

        1. Thank you Valerie. I am glad you like them😊. Because they are all hand-made and, with high-end materials, and often made to order, they do come at a cost…and of course not everyone’s cup if tea. Kind regards, Jay😊.

          Liked by 3 people

          Reply

    1. Thank you Darryl👍. I appreciate your support and kind comments. No worries….I haven’t had a lot of time to visit my own blog since the new year, things can get real busy sometimes can’t they. Best, Jay😊

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

    1. Hi Ajinkya😊. Yes, my apologies to everyone. I have pretty much taken the last year out. For several reasons really, mainly my Son is now off and studying at University so we both spent a good bit of time out preparing and adjusting for him to settle in successfully. I am now back & all is well👍! Thank you for noticing and your message😊. Kind regards, Jay.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

Leave a reply to Valerie Cullers Cancel reply